Customer Reviews
* FTC Disclaimer: The views and opinions expressed by contributors of the product reviews are their own and not necessarily those of Netrition.com. These reviews should not be taken as recommendations but rather customer opinions of the products that they may or may not have used. Furthermore, Netrition.com makes no warranty or representation, expressed or implied, as to the accuracy or sufficiency of the information contributed by outside sources, and assumes no responsibility or liability regarding the use of such information. Netrition.com does not warrant the performance, effectiveness or applicability of any materials listed or linked to on Netrition.com.
-
October 13, 2021Reviewer: Sarah in Missouri* Very good flavor and not overly sweet. I would definitely buy again.This review is specific to Keto Sandwich Cookies, Peanut Butter
-
October 13, 2021Reviewer: A customer in Missouri* Love these cookies. Some of the best keto friendly ones out thereThis review is specific to Keto Sandwich Cookies, Chocolate Vanilla
-
October 06, 2021Reviewer: Sandra in Missouri* A bit pricy but the cookies are great.This review is specific to Keto Sandwich Cookies, Chocolate Vanilla
-
October 03, 2021Reviewer: Linda in Virginia* Pretty good cookie when you need that little bit of sweet taste of a cookie on keto dietThis review is specific to Keto Sandwich Cookies, Peanut Butter
-
September 04, 2021Reviewer: Hilda in Colorado* They smell and taste like vanilla protein powder, so if you like that, then you might like these. You also get the slimy xanthan gum feel at the finish. Sad these didn't work outThis review is specific to Keto Sandwich Cookies, Vanilla Creme
-
August 27, 2021Reviewer: A customer in Colorado* These are really great cookies!
-
August 06, 2021Reviewer: BRIAN in Illinois* Taste great
-
3 of 3 people found the following review helpfulAugust 05, 2021Reviewer: David in Texas* I really wanted to like these cookies. The taste is good. They are a little crunchy, but they do not get stale after opening. The only problem is that they contain allulose, which causes massive amounts of gas and terrible cramps if I eat more than one. Why use a sweetener that causes so much gastric distress for so many people, with all of the other options available? I also don't understand how they can advertise these as keto when they contain cane sugar. It's time to reformulate these as a truly keto friendly product.
-
August 03, 2021Reviewer: LUCY in New York* These are really good when you are craving an oreo. The cookie part is a little harder then Oreo's but with some almond milk, they are delicious.This review is specific to Keto Sandwich Cookies, Chocolate Vanilla
-
July 28, 2021Reviewer: David in Texas* I don't know how they can advertise any product that contains cane sugar as keto. While they taste good, the allulose causes tremendous gas and cramps. Worse than maltitol.
-
July 07, 2021Reviewer: Steve in New York* While the cookies taste GREAT, and are a very good rendition of 'regular' cookies ... I give them low marks from the intestinal discomfort, wicked gas, and explosive diarrhea from the sugar alcohol used as a sweetener. Just 4 cookies make me offensive to be around! If they switched to Stevia or Monk Fruit I'd be all over these! Eat at your own risk!
-
July 04, 2021Reviewer: Lori in Arizona* They taste so good! So close to the non keto version.This review is specific to Keto Sandwich Cookies, Vanilla Creme
-
July 01, 2021Reviewer: Sujaan in New York* Love these for my low carb diet. They're not insanely sweet like Oreos but I still get to feel like I'm having something decadent. It's also a nice alternative to low carb bars. I love Catalina Crunch cereal too, very crunchy and satisfying.This review is specific to Keto Sandwich Cookies, Vanilla Creme
-
June 23, 2021Reviewer: Sherrie in Ohio* The cookies were actually delicious, but, the packaging had alot to be desired. Several cookies were totally crumbled and there were only 15 cookies in the package, instead of 16.This review is specific to Keto Sandwich Cookies, Vanilla Creme
-
June 10, 2021Reviewer: Rachael in Missouri* These are delicious! These are a "sometimes" treat for me because there is sugar in these and the carb count isn't extremely low, but when I am just absolutely craving oreo's, these hit the spot!!!This review is specific to Keto Sandwich Cookies, Chocolate Vanilla
-
May 29, 2021Reviewer: Linda in Israel* What a disappointment ! These "cookies" are as hard as dog biscuits and not only far too sweet, but have a strange after taste. We're going to have to throw them away. A real waste of money !This review is specific to Keto Sandwich Cookies, Vanilla Creme
-
May 28, 2021Reviewer: Janet in Ohio* I was pleasantly surprised by the texture and flavor of these cookies. They are crunchy and not too sweet like some Keto products are. I will be ordering more!This review is specific to Keto Sandwich Cookies, Peanut Butter
-
May 10, 2021Reviewer: A customer in Washington* I really like these cookies, so far I've purchased the Chocolate Vanilla and the Chocolate Mint. They have similarities to Oreo cookies and probably are the closest you'll find that you don't have to make yourself. The Mint is relatively mild, which I like and you could take them up a notch by coating them in sugar free Chocolate and putting them in the freezer. Now that the Peanut Butter are back in stock I'll be trying those next. The only thing I'd say is that the Chocolate flavor could be intensified, but I still like them and love the nice crunch.
-
May 08, 2021Reviewer: BARBARA in Illinois* GOOD PRODUCTThis review is specific to Keto Sandwich Cookies, Vanilla Creme
-
May 07, 2021Reviewer: Maria in Missouri* My rave review comes with a warning. These are incredibly delicious, taste is on point, and the vanilla cream is to die for.This review is specific to Keto Sandwich Cookies, Chocolate Vanilla
-
May 07, 2021Reviewer: Debra in Virginia* I ate 2 and then threw them away. I thought the taste was totally off and the texture seemed a little slimy as I was chewing. I have now tried the chocolate and the vanilla. I will not try any more.
-
April 30, 2021Reviewer: Howard in New Jersey* I purchased the chocolate-vanilla cookies. The taste is excellent! I truly enjoy them, and will purchase again in the future.This review is specific to Keto Sandwich Cookies, Chocolate Vanilla
-
April 28, 2021Reviewer: Evelyn in Connecticut* I did not like these. They have a rancid fat taste and not much flavor. I will not buy this flavor again. However, I did like the Chocolate Vanilla.This review is specific to Keto Sandwich Cookies, Vanilla Creme
-
April 24, 2021Reviewer: A customer in Oregon* The cookies themselves have a great crunch, and the filling is very creamy. But they just don't really taste like peanut butter. I'm pretty disappointed in the flavor.This review is specific to Keto Sandwich Cookies, Peanut Butter
-
April 18, 2021Reviewer: SHERRY in Tennessee* These , and the chocolate sandwich cookies, are fast becoming a favorite. Their flavor is good and satisfying. They are a bit crumbly, unless you put the whole cookie in your mouth at once! But they are a great treat and worth the money.
-
April 17, 2021Reviewer: MICHELLE in Pennsylvania* they were delicious!!!
-
April 12, 2021Reviewer: Maria J in Texas* Great taste! Even my husband who is very reluctant about Keto cookies loved them!This review is specific to Keto Sandwich Cookies, Vanilla Creme
-
April 07, 2021Reviewer: A customer in Texas* Very good cookies. I was pleasantly surprised.This review is specific to Keto Sandwich Cookies, Vanilla Creme
-
April 04, 2021Reviewer: Andrea in North Carolina* The peanut butter ones are legit. They are the best flavor so far to me!!This review is specific to Keto Sandwich Cookies, Peanut Butter
-
1 of 1 people found the following review helpfulMarch 29, 2021Reviewer: A customer in North Carolina* The good news is it is a very crunchy sandwich cookie. I love crunchy cookies and almost all keto cookies are soft or soft batch. Even supposed crispy cookies by other companies have a softer crispy feel. These are true crispy cookies. It tastes fine. Nothing special but it is fine.
The problem for me is there are 5 net carbs for 2 cookies. Now if these were out of this world fantastic just like the name-brand sandwich cookies I'd spend the 5 carbs once in a while. But they aren't. They are decent sandwich cookies. For me, they aren't nearly worth the carbs. This is the major reason I would not recommend them. However, if you are jonesing for a truly crispy cookie and don't care about the flavor as long as it is sweet, then this is the cookie for you.
This review is specific to Keto Sandwich Cookies, Chocolate Vanilla -
March 28, 2021Reviewer: Joanna in California* Have only had the chocolate oreo style but damn they are delish!! I will order the other flavors soon!This review is specific to Keto Sandwich Cookies, Chocolate Vanilla
-
March 27, 2021Reviewer: A customer in California* Taste like the real thing
-
March 22, 2021Reviewer: Eva in California* excellent product. tastes just like oreos, seriously couldn't tell the difference. def buying again!This review is specific to Keto Sandwich Cookies, Chocolate Vanilla
-
March 19, 2021Reviewer: A customer in Massachusetts* I thought these were great for what they are. Just a few would certainly curb a sweet tooth.This review is specific to Keto Sandwich Cookies, Chocolate Vanilla
-
March 04, 2021Reviewer: A customer in New York* These cookies are so yummy. The best low carb cookie I have tried thus far. They are very similar to the texture and taste of an Oreo, though not as sweet. I’ve tried the vanilla cream and the mint. Both are good, but the vanilla cream ones are better!This review is specific to Keto Sandwich Cookies, Vanilla Creme
-
March 02, 2021Reviewer: Sarah in Washington* amazing! but also expensive (like most keto products!) Could eat an entire box in a sitting.
-
March 02, 2021Reviewer: Andrea in New York* So good!! When you haven't been able to enjoy a good, crunchy Oreo, these hit the spot!! Can't wait to try the other flavors!!This review is specific to Keto Sandwich Cookies, Chocolate Vanilla
-
February 24, 2021Reviewer: karla in New York* I LOVE these cookies! I have tried all of the flavors except peanut butter. My fave is vanilla creme, super creamy and sweet without all the sugar! These are my go to snacks when I'm craving cookies. I'm looking forward to trying the peanut butter flavor next!
-
February 24, 2021Reviewer: CHRISTINE in Louisiana* Best tasting keto cookie out there!This review is specific to Keto Sandwich Cookies, Chocolate Vanilla
-
February 17, 2021Reviewer: Stephen in North Carolina* Delicious! Definitely one of my favorite keto snacks I’ve come across.
-
February 13, 2021Reviewer: Christine in Rhode Island* My favorite keto cookie!This review is specific to Keto Sandwich Cookies, Chocolate Vanilla
-
February 12, 2021Reviewer: Cynthia in Illinois* They taste just like oreo but without all the carb and processed ingredients. I buy these often.
-
February 06, 2021Reviewer: Cynthia in Pennsylvania* Big disappointment. Taste like sweet cardboard. The reviews fooled me. Not worth the carbs.
-
January 31, 2021Reviewer: Melvin in New York* Really tasty. A low carb substitute for Oreos.
-
January 28, 2021Reviewer: Katherine in Pennsylvania* So good crunchy cookie and the icing is better than Oreo's not greasy like an Oreo filling. Wish they had even more flavors. Lemon, vanilla cookie with chocolate icing are just some suggestions
-
January 27, 2021Reviewer: Linda in Michigan* These are the best keto cookies! Not too sweet, cookie is crisp and the filling is creamy.
-
January 21, 2021Reviewer: Cody in Louisiana* These are pretty good, not the best keto cookie I've ordered but I would buy again.
-
January 20, 2021Reviewer: Dee in Missouri* Just like Oreos
-
January 18, 2021Reviewer: A customer in Missouri* Oreos are back in my life
-
January 07, 2021Reviewer: Aaron in Tennessee* Tastes just like an Oreo. So glad to be able to have my "keto cookie and eat it too."
-
January 06, 2021Reviewer: Kathy in Connecticut* Wow! Never would have believed that a keto Oreo would taste good- it’s excellent!! An unmatched substitute for an Oreo!
-
January 06, 2021Reviewer: sheldon in Florida* Not quite like Oreos but it is really gooood
-
December 24, 2020Reviewer: Lisa in Michigan* These cookies were pretty good, a bit extra dry so make sure to have low carb milk with them but not bad at all. I would buy them again for a once in a while treat. No they will not replace an Oreo cookie but they come close enough to get that kind of cookie fix.
-
December 22, 2020Reviewer: Christina in California* The texture is great- very cookie-like and crisp. But the flavor leaves something to be desired. I would want a more chocolate-y taste. The cream is tasty. Overall, a good substitute for the real thing.
-
December 16, 2020Reviewer: Edward in California* Diabetic’s answer to oreo yearning!
-
December 15, 2020Reviewer: Dorine in Florida* Super flavor. Great crunch
-
December 10, 2020Reviewer: Amet in New York* Great option. Pretty close to Oreo flavor. Wish the inside wrapper had some kind of seal. Very Easy to keep eating.
-
December 03, 2020Reviewer: Pat in California* They are so good
-
November 16, 2020Reviewer: Karen in South Carolina* I like better than sugar chocolate sandwich cookies. No cravings after I eat one or two.
-
November 15, 2020Reviewer: A customer in South Carolina* Soggy, not very chocolate tasting and I was highly disappointed
-
November 11, 2020Reviewer: Theresa in Pennsylvania* Taste just like an Oreo. Super good
-
November 11, 2020Reviewer: A customer in Pennsylvania* It was my second time buying Catalina Crunch cookies here in this website.
-
November 11, 2020Reviewer: Vicki in Louisiana* Husband loves these.
-
November 08, 2020Reviewer: A customer in Louisiana* One of the best keto/low carb cookies I've ever had. Guilt free with a good taste.
-
November 05, 2020Reviewer: ELIZABETH in Ohio* A little on the flavorless side but still a good option to have when you're craving Oreos. If I could rate these 3.5 I would because I don't love them, but also they're fine for what they are. The cookie part is my favorite part of Oreos and the flavor of the cookies is just lacking. But yeah, give them a try, especially if you're a fan of cream filled sandwich style cookies.
-
November 01, 2020Reviewer: A customer in Ohio* I love Catalina crunch products!
-
October 30, 2020Reviewer: A customer in Ohio* Like the real deal!
-
October 28, 2020Reviewer: A customer in Wisconsin* tastes great, no after taste, will be ordering again.
-
October 23, 2020Reviewer: Lakisha in District of Columbia* Tastes awesome! A little sticky on the teeth but you’ll get over it for sure!
-
October 08, 2020Reviewer: Karen in Nebraska* These are deserving of the good reviews. They are excellent.
-
October 07, 2020Reviewer: Laurie in New Jersey* So good! They don’t taste like Oreos but they are still so delicious! Perfect with a cup of coffee.
-
October 07, 2020Reviewer: A customer in New Jersey* These are great Oreo substitutes! I’m addicted! Love them so much. Just wish they were lower carb and calorie, but then they probably wouldn’t taste as good!
-
October 06, 2020Reviewer: A customer in New York* The first time I had them I thought stye were ok but they really grew on me. Obviously not the same as Oreos but VERY solid. The icing is good and the cookie is nice and crunch!
-
October 05, 2020Reviewer: A guest* These cookies are really good. I haven't had a cookie in such a long time. Was very happy with my purchase!
-
October 04, 2020Reviewer: A customer in Nebraska* These are not quite as good as the original Oreo but they are quite good! A little pricey but that goes with the territory.
-
October 04, 2020Reviewer: Leah in New York* These are so good!!! My favorite way is putting them in the fridge for some Reason they taste so much better that way.
-
September 27, 2020Reviewer: A guest* I love these cookies, and fall in love for them from the first sight, I was avoiding all types of similar cookies at all cost because of sugar, calories, carbs, or all those evil add ons and these cookies worth every bite in my opinion.
-
September 26, 2020Reviewer: Elizabeth in Virginia* The cookies taste like a cheap brand of sandwich cookie. I wouldn’t order them again.
-
September 22, 2020Reviewer: A customer in Florida* Pretty good Oreo dupe!
-
September 15, 2020Reviewer: James in Massachusetts* Fairly amazing taste and crunchy texture and I've tried many keto low carb cookies.....
-
September 08, 2020Reviewer: Darlene in Maryland* Very tasty cookies. As others have said, similar to Oreos but obviously not 100% the same taste. They really satisfy your sweet craving, usually eating 2 at a time is all I need. It's nice to eat sandwich cookies again without feeling guilty. The price is high for only 16 cookies but I will definitely be purchasing these again in the future.
-
September 03, 2020Reviewer: Heidi in Missouri* These do taste really similar to Oreos and satisfy that urge. They do leave a very bizarre aftertaste, though.
-
August 31, 2020Reviewer: Julie in California* Taste just like oreo.
-
August 31, 2020Reviewer: A guest* thought they tasted pretty good
-
August 30, 2020Reviewer: Susan in Maine* The best oreo ! Without all the sugar and carbs!!
-
August 30, 2020Reviewer: A guest* I really enjoy the texture and taste of this cookie. It is not too sweet and has the right combination of crunch and cream. It may leave a slight aftertaste for those unaccustomed to keto sweeteners. The price is also high for the amount of product. But, overall, I am pleased with the purchase.
-
August 29, 2020Reviewer: Nancy in Ohio* As a huge fan of their cereals I knew these would be a hit, and they absolutely are! They have a nice chocolaty crunch with a delicious creamy filling. There is no funky aftertaste and satisfy just like a sugar laden cookie without all the bad stuff. I’m looking forward to more delicious flavors!
-
August 29, 2020Reviewer: Chrislie in Michigan* These were just like eating regular Oreo Cookies. I made myself a cold glass of milk and dunked these cookies in it. They were delicious. I'd like to see a larger package of these for sale.
-
August 29, 2020Reviewer: Janice in Florida* These are DELICIOUS!! I have been wanting to try these since they first launched and I was super stoked when Netrition started to carry them! I ordered one box to start...I just placed another order for 2 more boxes, these will be on my list for reorder every time I place an order here. They do no taste exactly like oreos but they are pretty dang close and they are super good for what they are! Like another reviewer stated, "they remind me of the sandwich cookies that are sold in small packs under the Lance brand". Super yummy and absolutely fill my craving for an oreo cookie!
-
August 27, 2020Reviewer: Rene in Texas* Pleasantly surprised! These are not oreo cookies, so if you expect that trademark taste, you're not going to like these. They're not as sweet or as chocolaty but they do taste good and they have a nice texture. There is no weird aftertaste and the cookie part is nice and crispy.
-
2 of 2 people found the following review helpfulAugust 21, 2020Reviewer: Vanessa in Ohio* Was anxious to try as we have been craving a sandwich cookie since going keto last September. I usually bake keto cookies, but its summer, and who wants to bake? These were delicious! They remind me of the sandwich cookies that are sold in small packs under the Lance brand. They are not waxy, the cream inside is not sickeningly sweet, and the cookie has a good, crunchy texture. The flavor is great, and no aftertaste. Kudos to not adding a bunch of sugar alcohols, which sometimes leave a bitter finish. Highly recommend and looking forward to more from this brand. Thanks for satisfying our sandwich cookie craving!