Customer Reviews
* FTC Disclaimer: The views and opinions expressed by contributors of the product reviews are their own and not necessarily those of Netrition.com. These reviews should not be taken as recommendations but rather customer opinions of the products that they may or may not have used. Furthermore, Netrition.com makes no warranty or representation, expressed or implied, as to the accuracy or sufficiency of the information contributed by outside sources, and assumes no responsibility or liability regarding the use of such information. Netrition.com does not warrant the performance, effectiveness or applicability of any materials listed or linked to on Netrition.com.
-
September 19, 2021Reviewer: A customer in New York* Very peanutty flavor. Sticky on my fingers, but good on your tongue. Can enjoy for a long time until totally dissolves, or bit into it for a "butterfinger" texture.
-
August 07, 2021Reviewer: A customer in New York* These are so good! I can never eat just one!
-
July 14, 2021Reviewer: Karen in Maine* I love this candy! It's just the thing for a sweet treat. 20 calories and zero net carbs per piece. I would highly recommend.
-
June 20, 2021Reviewer: pam in Georgia* This is my go to sugar free candy.
-
May 30, 2021Reviewer: JAN A in Iowa* These are my diabetic son's favorite. They seemed fresh and he loved them.
-
May 22, 2021Reviewer: Shirley in Arkansas* Will order again. Couldn't tell they were sugar free.
-
April 20, 2021Reviewer: Nancy in Ohio* I loved these growing up and the flavor has not changed! My only regret is the Splenda. Which is why I will not purchase again. It would be great to see more healthy and organic sweeteners used instead of the poisonous Splenda. I gave these 5 stars because they taste terrific but are not healthy.
-
April 13, 2021Reviewer: A customer in California* Three of these for one Weight Watchers point! You can't beat it. They are delicious too!
-
April 09, 2021Reviewer: Victoria in Georgia* These along with the Chico sticks are the best sugar free candies I have ever had. I have tried so many different kinds and these two are 100 times better then any other kind. They taste just like the real ones.
-
February 24, 2021Reviewer: Anne in North Carolina* I ordered them thinking it would be like some of the penny candy my grandfather bought me as a child. I was not disappointed. What great memories when I ate the first piece. There was only one problem—just like a child, I couldn’t stop with just one or two pieces. I could, however, have a smile!
-
January 27, 2021Reviewer: fanessa in Texas* If you are on Keto and are craving something sweet, this will hit the spot. Pretty close to the real thing!
-
December 28, 2020Reviewer: A customer in Texas* Really tasty. Doesn't seem sugar free.
-
November 29, 2020Reviewer: James in Arizona* Compares well with full sugared version. Crunchy an melty at the same time. Thanks for this treat.
-
November 25, 2020Reviewer: Lisa in Virginia* My new favorite
-
November 22, 2020Reviewer: Angela in Mississippi* Grew up eating these. So excited to find a sugar free version. Taste pretty much the same as the original. Definitely recommend.
-
September 12, 2020Reviewer: LaRhonda in Tennessee* Love these. Crunchy and peanut buttery!
-
June 14, 2020Reviewer: Robert in New York* They are tasty and have a nice crunch. They have a strong vanilla taste which almost masks the peanut butter. If they made it more peanut butter flavored it would definitely taste like the center of a butter Finger.
-
May 21, 2020Reviewer: Sheryl in Florida* These are so good! They are just like the center of a butterfinger. I just ordered 4 more bags!
-
April 08, 2020Reviewer: catherine in Tennessee* Great taste and crunchy texture
-
April 05, 2020Reviewer: A customer in Tennessee* These are just ok. I was hoping for significant peanut butter flavor. It's there, but it's just a hint. They aren't bad, just not what I hoped for. No point in wasting the money, calories or carbs on this one.
-
February 26, 2020Reviewer: A customer in New York* Very close to a little Clark bar type taste, very good sugar free treat.
-
January 20, 2020Reviewer: Antonio in Virginia* A great treat when you're on Keto. They taste like candy from my childhood, sweet and nutty. There's no aftertaste.
-
November 02, 2019Reviewer: Sarah in Missouri* Amazing! They taste like the real thing minus the sugar.
-
October 30, 2019Reviewer: Lisa in California* This product is dangerous! 2 reasons; they are ridiculous tasty so you eat waaaay too many of them at one sitting, but also because they are made with Splenda which is not the best thing for you versus other natural sweeteners. But I still love them!
-
September 24, 2019Reviewer: joanne in California* Taste was great,it a very low cab sweet treat. I will purchase again.
-
May 14, 2019Reviewer: CAROLYN in California* Delicious! Enjoyed these as a kid and now I can enjoy them as adult. I taste no difference between the regular ones and these sugar free ones. Will definitely be buying again!
-
April 24, 2019Reviewer: Sharon in South Dakota* Love these! Will definitely keep ordering.
-
April 12, 2019Reviewer: A customer in South Carolina* Excellent!! Great peanut butter flavor without the aftertaste.
-
2 of 2 people found the following review helpfulFebruary 21, 2019Reviewer: Roni in Ohio* It has a slight rubbing alcohol taste when you first put it in your mouth. Too many can cause multiple trips to the bathroom, too.
-
December 20, 2018Reviewer: A customer in Illinois* Tastes like regular candy to me. I like that it is sweetened with splenda. I would buy them again.
-
November 11, 2018Reviewer: Rita J in Washington* Delicious! One of my favorite low carb treats.
-
November 04, 2018Reviewer: Stephanie in Maryland* Taste is fine. Candy is kinda hard on the teeth though, so I'm not sure I'd order again. Could be a lifesaver at Halloween though.
-
May 05, 2018Reviewer: Diana in Florida* Being on a low carb diet is hard for someone like me that loves sweets but these are delicious and taste just like the ones with real sugar! These are my absolute favorite and I will be buying these from now on!
-
April 24, 2018Reviewer: Melody in Pennsylvania* These are delicious. You can't tell they're sugar free.
-
April 04, 2018Reviewer: A customer in Tennessee* Excellent- only problem is I want to eat too many.
-
March 26, 2018Reviewer: CLARA in South Carolina* This is a great pick me up when you want that something sweet. Tastes better than the sugar version. Gotta try them!
-
February 26, 2018Reviewer: Linda in Michigan* These are fantastic, can't believe they are sugar free. I keep ordering these, love them so much.
-
January 18, 2018Reviewer: Carmen in Kansas* I was expecting that crunchy wafer, peanut buttery goodness, but instead the candy just stuck to my teeth. Not a fan.
-
January 10, 2018Reviewer: Joseph in North Carolina* These are fantastic for a candy snack if you are on a low carb diet. They taste great; just like the "old days" bars. I would highly recommend as a 20 calorie snack / treat.
-
January 07, 2018Reviewer: A customer in Virginia* A bit pricey but tasted good.
-
December 24, 2017Reviewer: cathy in North Carolina* This item was good
-
January 29, 2017Reviewer: Tracey in Washington* Love them! Another candy that reminds me of my childhood. (back in the 60's)
-
July 26, 2016Reviewer: David in Maryland* These are absolutely amazing. They taste like a "real" candy, with sort of a Clark bar center. Some of these are going to make their way into every order I place.
-
January 11, 2016Reviewer: Rhiannon in New York* I LOVE these. They are just like the middle of a Butterfinger, but sugar free! My only complaint is the sugar alcohols - otherwise I'd give them a 5. I wish more products could be made with natural sweeteners like Stevia or Monk fruit instead!!
-
November 06, 2015Reviewer: Randall in Alabama* These are great for Sugar Free low carb snacks.
-
March 21, 2015Reviewer: Maggie in Tennessee* Delicious. Tastes just like the peanut butters bars I ate as a child that were full of sugar. Great to know that they are available in the sugar free version.
-
March 20, 2015Reviewer: A customer in Virginia* These taste just like the "peanut butter logs" of my childhood...can not tell they are sugar-free. Yummy!
-
March 20, 2015Reviewer: Barbara in Massachusetts* Very delicious! When you need something sweet, these do the trick. Excellent peanut butter taste!
-
December 02, 2014Reviewer: Carol in Texas* These Atkinson's Sugar Free Peanut Butter Bars candy taste identical to the regular version! They are great for people eating low carb to have a sweet treat and the price is very reasonable.
-
5 of 5 people found the following review helpfulJuly 24, 2014Reviewer: James in Texas* Oh my goodness!!! A 60 point spike in blood glucose after eating this. Before eating 114, after 30 minutes 174!
If you are diabetic, avoid this. All the Atkinson's products I just bought are headed to the trash.
-
July 14, 2014Reviewer: Kelly in Louisiana* Almost identical to the original.
-
March 18, 2014Reviewer: Suzanne in California* WOW! These are really good!! Thanks! I am going to order more! Crunchy with a peanut butter burst!
-
March 03, 2014Reviewer: Britany in Florida* I love these!!!! I will be ordering these often! When I am craving peanut butter or just something sweet, I grab these!
-
November 04, 2013Reviewer: marcia in Massachusetts* I am thrilled Netrition will be carrying them. They are absolutely delicious . It takes a lot of willpower not to eat the whole bag.